Still Can't Explain

Case file · Eyewitness accounts · Case status: Partly explained

The Phoenix Lights: what witnesses saw over Arizona on 13 March 1997

The Phoenix Lights were two separate events. The row of lights that hung over Phoenix at about 10pm is well explained as military flares; the V-shaped formation seen earlier across Arizona is widely attributed to aircraft that were never officially identified.

By The Unexplained News desk. Published . 7 min read.

Case status: Partly explained. Some of what was reported has a solid explanation. Some of it doesn't.

Where: Phoenix, Arizona, United States. When: 13 March 1997.

Key facts

  • On 13 March 1997, witnesses across Arizona reported a silent V-shaped formation of lights crossing the state between about 8pm and 8.45pm, then a separate row of bright, hovering lights south-west of Phoenix at about 10pm.
  • In July 1997 the Maryland Air National Guard said its A-10 jets, in Arizona for Operation Snowbird winter training, had dropped parachute flares from about 4,600m (15,000ft) over the Barry M. Goldwater Air Force Range that night.
  • Video analysis by the firm Cognitech for the Discovery Channel found the 10pm lights sat above the Sierra Estrella mountains and went out as they reached the ridge, as distant flares sinking behind it would.
  • The earlier V was never officially identified: an amateur astronomer saw planes through his telescope, but no base or airport claimed the flight and FAA radar tapes were not preserved.
  • Arizona's governor, Fife Symington, mocked the sightings at a press conference on 19 June 1997 by unveiling his chief of staff in an alien costume; in 2007 he said he had seen an enormous craft himself that night.

On the evening of Thursday 13 March 1997, people across Arizona looked up and saw lights they could not account for. First, a V-shaped formation glided silently south-east across the state, over Prescott and Phoenix and on past Tucson. Then, at about 10pm, a row of brilliant orbs appeared to hang over the desert south-west of Phoenix before winking out one by one.

Together they became the Phoenix Lights, seen by hundreds, possibly thousands, of people. The sceptical writer Robert Sheaffer calls the 10pm display alone “perhaps the most widely witnessed UFO event in history”. Nearly 30 years on, the later lights have a well-documented military explanation, while the earlier formation, which many witnesses still describe as one enormous craft, was never officially identified.

What witnesses saw on the night of 13 March 1997

Many people were already outside that evening looking at Comet Hale-Bopp, as bright a comet as had been seen in 20 years. According to a detailed reconstruction by Phoenix New Times, the V passed over the Prescott area at about 8.15pm, over Phoenix some 15 minutes later and south of Tucson by 8.45pm.

Accounts vary in their details, with five, six or seven lights, but the shape recurs: a chevron moving slowly and without a sound. Tim Ley, watching with his family from their home in Phoenix, told CNN that when the right side of what looked like a giant V passed directly over him, the left side was a couple of blocks away.

When it finally got here and we realized this thing was coming right over us, we really started getting antsy.

— Tim Ley, in a CNN report, June 1997

His wife, Bobbi, said it “didn’t seem threatening”, adding: “When it was right overhead and we couldn’t hear a sound, it was like you’re just awestruck.” Chris McLennan, watching the comet through a telescope in north Phoenix, saw seven glowing orbs. “They just didn’t look man-made,” she told Phoenix New Times for an oral history of the night.

The actor Kurt Russell, a pilot, said on the BBC’s The One Show in 2017 that while landing that evening he saw “six lights over the airport — absolutely uniform — in a V-shape”, and reported them. KTAR News noted that he left out details such as which airport.

Not everyone saw a craft. Mitch Stanley, a 21-year-old amateur astronomer in Scottsdale, turned his 25cm (10in) Dobsonian telescope on the formation. At 60 times magnification, New Times reported, each light split into a pair on the tips of squarish wings. “They were planes. There’s no way I could have mistaken that,” he told the paper in 1997.

The 10pm lights and the flare explanation

At about 10pm a second display began: up to nine bright lights south-west of the city that seemed to hover for several minutes, then vanished one after another towards the Sierra Estrella mountains. They were filmed all over the Phoenix area. Mike Krzyston, who caught all nine on tape from his garden, exclaimed that he had “hit pay dirt” as they appeared.

Military officials said at first that they had nothing in the air over Phoenix. Then, in July 1997, after an Arizona Air National Guard spokeswoman, Capt Eileen Bienz, made her own inquiries, the Maryland Air National Guard’s spokesman said, according to the Associated Press, that its A-10 ground-attack jets had been dropping high-intensity parachute flares from about 4,600m (15,000ft) over the Barry M. Goldwater Air Force Range south-west of Phoenix. They were in Arizona for Operation Snowbird, which brings aircraft from northern bases to train there in winter. Before flying back to Davis-Monthan Air Force Base in Tucson, the planes jettisoned their remaining flares, which he said would have created what one pilot called “one hell of a light show”.

For a Discovery Channel programme, Leonid Rudin of the image-processing firm Cognitech lined up Krzyston’s night footage with a daytime shot from the same spot: the lights sat above the Estrella ridge and blinked out as they reached it, as distant flares sinking behind the mountains would. Paul Scowen, an Arizona State University astronomer, repeated the test for New Times with the same result. The Maryland flight leader, Ed Jones, later confirmed the drop to James McGaha, a retired US Air Force pilot, according to an article in Skeptical Inquirer that McGaha wrote with the investigator Joe Nickell. Even some UFO proponents, such as the journalist Leslie Kean, accept that a key video of the 10pm lights shows flares, the article notes.

Others hold out. Krzyston insisted the lights hovered in front of the mountains, not behind them. Lynne Kitei, a Phoenix physician who filmed lights from her home that night and later gave up medicine to research them, argues they could not have been flares. “It seemed too perfect to be flares. But it also wasn’t moving like aircraft,” Stacy Holmstedt, who watched from her car, told New Times.

The V-shaped formation and the aircraft explanation

The flares cannot account for the first sighting, which came about 90 minutes earlier and crossed almost the whole state. Sceptics point to Stanley’s telescope and to a video of the formation shot by Terry Proctor, in which, New Times reported, the five lights shift position relative to one another, so they were separate objects rather than one solid body. Sheaffer argues that they were five A-10s from Operation Snowbird returning from Nellis Air Force Base near Las Vegas to Davis-Monthan along the main air corridor, showing formation lights rather than the usual blinking collision lights. McGaha and Nickell say they were the Maryland squadron itself, and that bright lights outlining a triangle make fainter stars inside it hard to see, giving the impression of a solid mass.

It was clearly aircraft in formation, flying at two different times and then dropping flares and it’s clear to any rational person that’s what it was.

— James McGaha, astronomer and retired US Air Force pilot, to the Associated Press, March 2007

But the planes were never identified on the record. The Maryland Guard’s spokesman told New Times that its A-10s never went north of Phoenix that night, so could not have been the 8.30pm formation, and no base or airport came forward to claim the flight. Radar might have settled it, but nobody formally asked the Federal Aviation Administration for its tapes by 28 March 1997, the deadline for keeping a permanent record, the FAA told the paper.

Governor Symington’s alien press conference

The story went global in June, after USA Today put the sightings on its front page on 18 June 1997. The next day, during a lunch break in his federal fraud trial, Arizona’s governor, Fife Symington, promised a state investigation. “We’re going to get to the bottom of it,” he told reporters, the Deseret News reported.

Later that day, with at least two television stations broadcasting live, he announced that a suspect was in custody. In walked a glittery alien with a big head and googly eyes. Inside the costume was his chief of staff, Jay Heiler.

This just goes to show you guys are entirely too serious.

— Governor Fife Symington, press conference, 19 June 1997, as reported by the Deseret News

Many witnesses were not amused. “He comes marching out and made a mockery of it, which was really disconcerting,” Kitei told New Times. Frances Emma Barwood, a Phoenix city councilwoman who had called for an investigation, was widely ridiculed; in July she dismissed the flare explanation as too convenient and demanded a re-enactment, the AP reported.

What Symington later said he saw

A decade later, Symington changed his account. In March 2007 he told the Associated Press that he had seen a UFO himself that night; he has said he kept quiet at the time because he did not want people to panic.

I’m a pilot and I know just about every machine that flies. It was bigger than anything that I’ve ever seen.

— Fife Symington, former governor of Arizona, to the Associated Press, March 2007

In a commentary for CNN that November, the former Air Force officer described a “massive delta-shaped” craft with “enormous lights” passing silently over a mountain in Phoenix as he looked for the reported lights. He wrote that he had staged the costume stunt to “lighten the mood” and “never meant to ridicule anyone”, and that what he saw was “certainly not high-altitude flares because flares don’t fly in formation”. In the 2021 Showtime series UFO he added that, under federal indictment at the time, he “didn’t want to pour any kerosene on the fire”.

Sceptics are unmoved. McGaha told the AP that Symington “is not a trained observer and what he feels in his gut doesn’t make any difference”. He and Nickell also accuse Symington of confusing the two events: the flare explanation was only ever offered for the 10pm lights, not for the earlier V he describes.

What we still can’t explain

Little mystery remains about the 10pm lights. The unit that dropped the flares acknowledged it, the time and place fit, and the video matches flares sinking behind the Sierra Estrella. Some witnesses and researchers still dispute it, but the evidence for flares has not been overturned.

The V is a different matter. The best evidence, a telescope sighting and a video showing the lights moving independently, points to aircraft in formation, on a route that sceptics say matches a military flight returning to Tucson. Yet no military unit has publicly confirmed flying it, the Maryland Guard said its jets were never north of Phoenix, and the radar data that might have settled it was not kept. Without those records, the accounts of the many people who describe a vast, silent shape passing low overhead may never be reconciled with that explanation.

If you saw something you couldn’t explain, tell us your story, or read our guide on how to report a UFO sighting. For another mass sighting, see the Ariel School case in Zimbabwe.

Questions people ask

What were the Phoenix Lights?

The Phoenix Lights were two separate sightings over Arizona on the evening of 13 March 1997. Between about 8pm and 8.45pm, a V-shaped formation of five to seven lights moved silently south-east across the state, passing over Phoenix at about 8.30pm. At about 10pm, up to nine bright lights appeared to hover south-west of Phoenix before disappearing one by one. Hundreds, possibly thousands, of people saw them, and many filmed the later lights.

Were the Phoenix Lights ever explained?

The Phoenix Lights are only partly explained. In July 1997 the Maryland Air National Guard said its A-10 jets, training in Arizona under Operation Snowbird, had dropped parachute flares over the Barry M. Goldwater Air Force Range that night, and video analysis supports that explanation for the 10pm lights. Sceptics attribute the earlier V-shaped formation to military aircraft flying in formation, but those planes were never identified on the record and the radar tapes were not kept.

What did Fife Symington say about the Phoenix Lights?

Arizona's governor, Fife Symington, mocked the Phoenix Lights at a press conference on 19 June 1997, when his chief of staff, Jay Heiler, appeared in an alien costume. In March 2007 Symington said he had seen a huge craft himself that night and had kept quiet to avoid panic. In a CNN commentary that November he described a massive delta-shaped craft and wrote that flares don't fly in formation.

Were the Phoenix Lights flares?

The later Phoenix Lights, seen at about 10pm on 13 March 1997, are well explained as illumination flares dropped by Maryland Air National Guard A-10 jets over a bombing range south-west of Phoenix. Video analysis showed the lights going out as they sank behind the Sierra Estrella mountains. Flares do not explain the V-shaped formation seen about 90 minutes earlier, which sceptics attribute to aircraft flying in formation.

Sources

  1. Military now says flares may be cause of mysterious Arizona lights, Las Vegas Sun (Associated Press) (25 July 1997)
  2. The Hack and the Quack, Phoenix New Times (5 March 1998)
  3. What were those lights in the Phoenix sky?, CNN (Internet Archive copy) (19 June 1997)
  4. Former Ariz. governor boosts UFO claims, NBC News (Associated Press) (23 March 2007)
  5. Symington: I saw a UFO in the Arizona sky, CNN (9 November 2007)
  6. 'Alien' encounter leaves media agog, Deseret News (20 June 1997)
  7. Alien Lights? At Phoenix, Stephenville, and Elsewhere: A Postmortem, Skeptical Inquirer (1 March 2015)
  8. The ‘Phoenix Lights’ Become an ‘Incident’, Skeptical Inquirer (8 November 2016)
  9. Phoenix Lights UFO sightings in 1997: An oral history, Phoenix New Times (13 March 2025)
  10. Was actor Kurt Russell the pilot who reported the Phoenix Lights?, KTAR News (13 June 2017)

Unexplained News is researched and written with the help of AI tools, working only from the public sources linked in each article. We keep what's documented apart from what's claimed, and we correct mistakes openly. Spotted a mistake? Email [email protected]. Our editorial standards. This article in plain Markdown.

Seen something you can't explain? Tell us your story.

Read next