Still Can't Explain

Case file · UAP & UFOs · Case status: Unexplained

The Nimitz 'Tic Tac' UFO encounter: what Navy pilots saw off Baja California in 2004

On 14 November 2004, two Navy F/A-18F crews sent by the cruiser USS Princeton reported a smooth, wingless white object that outmanoeuvred them off Baja California. More than two decades on, the Pentagon still lists the case as unresolved.

By The Unexplained News desk. Published . 6 min read.

Case status: Unexplained. No accepted conventional explanation, and the evidence or testimony is credible enough to take seriously.

Where: Pacific Ocean south-west of San Diego, off Baja California, Mexico. When: 14 November 2004.

Key facts

  • On 14 November 2004 the cruiser USS Princeton sent two F/A-18F Super Hornets from USS Nimitz to an unknown contact about 30 nautical miles off Mexico's coast, south-west of San Diego.
  • Cdr David Fravor told a House Oversight subcommittee on 26 July 2023 that he and his crews saw a white, wingless 'Tic Tac' object that accelerated away when he closed to about half a mile.
  • A Navy briefing slide released under the Freedom of Information Act describes the object as 'solid white, smooth, with no edges', about 46 feet (14 m) long, with very limited data for analysis.
  • The FLIR1 infrared video was recorded later the same day by Chad Underwood, a pilot in Fravor's squadron; the Pentagon officially released it on 27 April 2020.
  • The New York Times made the encounter public on 16 December 2017, in reporting that revealed the Pentagon's $22 million Advanced Aerospace Threat Identification Program.
  • As of October 2026, the Pentagon's All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office lists the FLIR video as an unresolved case; sceptic Mick West argues the footage fits a distant aircraft.

On 14 November 2004, about 30 nautical miles (56 km) off Mexico’s Pacific coast, south-west of San Diego, two US Navy F/A-18F Super Hornets from the carrier USS Nimitz were sent by the cruiser USS Princeton to check an unknown radar contact. Their aviators, led by Cdr David Fravor, reported a smooth, white, wingless object shaped like a Tic Tac mint that outmanoeuvred them and vanished (Navy briefing slide).

Later that day another crew recorded an object on infrared, and that clip, FLIR1, became one of three Navy videos the Pentagon formally released in 2020. The encounter has since become one of the most widely discussed military UFO cases: a pilot has testified to Congress, sceptics have picked apart the video, and the Pentagon’s UFO office still lists it as unresolved.

What the USS Princeton’s radar tracked

The story begins days earlier. From around 10 November 2004, according to New York magazine’s reporting, Princeton radar operator Kevin Day saw groups of slow-moving objects off San Clemente Island at about 28,000 feet (8.5 km). Over roughly two weeks the crew tried to identify them, including shutting down and recalibrating the radar to rule out false “ghost tracks” (Intelligencer).

Fravor later told Congress the controller said the objects had been seen for over two weeks “coming down from over 80,000 feet, rapidly descending to 20,000 feet, hanging out for hours and then going straight back up” (hearing transcript). That is roughly 24 km down to 6 km. No radar recordings have been made public; Fravor says the tape from his squadron’s jets was never released.

What Fravor and Dietrich reported

Fravor, commanding officer of the Black Aces squadron, VFA-41, was leading a training flight with a second jet flown by Alex Dietrich, a pilot in his squadron who later retired as a lieutenant commander (Task & Purpose). Each jet carried a weapons systems officer in the back seat. The Princeton suspended the exercise and sent them towards the contact.

At about 20,000 feet they saw a patch of churning white water on an otherwise calm sea. Above it, Fravor testified, was “a white Tic Tac object with a longitudinal axis pointing north south and moving very abruptly over the water like a ping pong ball”, with no rotors, rotor wash or wings. Dietrich stayed high while Fravor spiralled down. The object turned to face his jet and climbed. When he closed to about half a mile (800 m), “it rapidly accelerated in front of us and disappeared”.

Sir, you are not going to believe this, but that thing is at your CAP point roughly 60 miles away in less than a minute.

— Princeton controller, as recalled by Cdr David Fravor to the House Oversight subcommittee, 26 July 2023

The CAP point was the pair’s planned holding position, about 100 km (60 miles) away. The Navy’s own briefing slide describes the object as “solid white, smooth, with no edges”, with no “nacelles, pylons, or wings”, and about 46 feet (14 m) long. Dietrich, speaking publicly for the first time on CBS’s 60 Minutes in 2021, recalled “No predictable movement, no predictable trajectory” (CBS News).

The FLIR1 video and the pilot who filmed it

Back on the Nimitz, Fravor told a crew about to launch what he had seen. On that later flight Chad Underwood, another pilot in the squadron, picked up a contact on radar and on his jet’s infrared targeting pod and recorded the clip now known as FLIR1. He also coined the name “Tic Tac”.

FLIR1 does not show Fravor’s own encounter. Underwood told New York magazine in 2019 that the object’s changes in altitude, airspeed and aspect were “just unlike things that I’ve ever encountered before flying against other air targets”, and that he saw no exhaust plume. He was candid about the clip’s famous ending, when the object darts left: “I did not actually see the object aggressively accelerate to the left, as the video shows, to actually prove that.”

How the story became public

Copies of FLIR1 circulated online after an unauthorised release in 2007. The story reached a mass audience on 16 December 2017, when The New York Times revealed the Advanced Aerospace Threat Identification Program, a $22 million Pentagon effort that began in 2007, largely at the request of Senator Harry Reid, and that the Defense Department said it had shut down in 2012 (New York Times). The Times reported that the program was run by the military intelligence official Luis Elizondo, and published Fravor’s account alongside it.

On 27 April 2020 the Pentagon formally released FLIR1 together with two Navy videos from January 2015.

DOD is releasing the videos in order to clear up any misconceptions by the public on whether or not the footage that has been circulating was real, or whether or not there is more to the videos.

— US Department of Defense statement, 27 April 2020

The statement added that the phenomena “remain characterized as ‘unidentified’” (Pentagon statement). The Navy slide, later released under the Freedom of Information Act, helps explain why so little evidence survives: “Reporting terminated at 3rd Fleet, there was no process to share the reporting.” It also records “a large amount of harassment and ridicule throughout the Nimitz”.

Fravor’s testimony to Congress in July 2023

On 26 July 2023 Fravor testified under oath to the House Oversight subcommittee on national security, the border and foreign affairs, alongside the former Navy pilot Ryan Graves and the former intelligence official David Grusch. He said the incident “was never investigated” and that none of his crew were questioned. Asked what astonished him most, he replied: “The performance. Absolute performance.” He added: “I think it is far beyond, actually, our material science that we currently possess.”

The sceptical case

The sceptical investigator Mick West set out his view of FLIR1 in October 2017 on his Metabunk forum. The footage, he wrote, “seems consistent with a distant (>50 miles away) plane flying away from the camera”, and a sudden switch between 1x and 2x zoom makes its final drift “look vastly more dramatic than it actually is” (Metabunk). He concluded the incident “likely consisted of dodgy radar returns and a distant plane not on the radar”.

Underwood rejects the idea that his own manoeuvring caused the dart, saying his jet was pointed nose-on and not turning hard, while conceding he cannot confirm the acceleration. The eyewitness accounts are harder to test, and Dietrich herself is cautious: she told Task & Purpose it would be “arrogant”, “reckless” and “foolish” to draw conclusions about what she saw.

What AARO has said

The Pentagon’s All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office, established in 2022, lists the clip on its official imagery page as “Unresolved Case: FLIR Video” as of October 2026. It has published a case resolution for the 2015 GoFast video, but none for FLIR1. Sean Kirkpatrick, AARO’s first director, said in January 2024 that “Most of the time when we can’t give an explanation, it is because there is a lack of data”, pointing to the Tic Tac case; he said there were multiple possible explanations but too little data to choose between them (Newsweek). For more on the office, see what AARO is and what it does.

What we still can’t explain

Fravor says four aviators watched the object for about five minutes in clear weather, and the Princeton’s operators say they had tracked similar contacts for days. Yet almost none of the hard data that could settle the case is public: no radar recordings, no full sensor files, only a short infrared clip that sceptics and witnesses read in opposite ways. The claim that the object crossed about 100 km in under a minute rests on a controller’s call and the pilots’ memories.

Until more data is released, if it still exists, the Tic Tac remains, in the Pentagon’s own word, “unidentified”. For efforts in Congress to force the release of UAP records, see our report on the UAP Disclosure Act.

Questions people ask

What was the Nimitz Tic Tac UFO?

The Nimitz Tic Tac was an unidentified object reported on 14 November 2004 by US Navy aviators from the carrier USS Nimitz, about 30 nautical miles off Mexico's Pacific coast. Cdr David Fravor and Alex Dietrich, sent by the cruiser USS Princeton to check a radar contact, described a smooth white object about 14 m (46 ft) long, with no wings, that accelerated away and vanished.

Who filmed the Tic Tac UFO video?

The Tic Tac video, known as FLIR1, was recorded on 14 November 2004 by Chad Underwood, a pilot in Cdr David Fravor's squadron, using his F/A-18's infrared targeting pod on a later flight that day. Underwood coined the name Tic Tac. The video does not show Fravor's own close encounter, which happened earlier and was not filmed.

Has the Nimitz Tic Tac encounter been explained?

No. As of October 2026 the Pentagon's All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office lists the FLIR video from the Nimitz encounter as an unresolved case. Its first director, Sean Kirkpatrick, said a lack of data prevented a firm answer. Sceptics such as Mick West argue the video fits a distant aircraft, while the pilots say what they saw at close range had no wings or visible propulsion.

Is the Nimitz Tic Tac video real?

Yes. The US Department of Defense formally released the Nimitz FLIR1 video, with two other Navy videos from 2015, on 27 April 2020. It said it did so to clear up misconceptions about whether the circulating footage was real, and that the aerial phenomena in the videos remained characterised as unidentified. Copies had circulated online since an unauthorised release in 2007.

What did David Fravor tell Congress about the Tic Tac?

On 26 July 2023 retired Cdr David Fravor testified under oath to a House Oversight subcommittee that he saw a white Tic Tac object over the Pacific in 2004 that accelerated away from his jet. He said the incident was never investigated, his crew were never questioned, and the object's performance was beyond any technology he knew of.

Sources

  1. Statement by the Department of Defense on the Release of Historical Navy Videos, US Department of War (formerly Department of Defense) (27 April 2020)
  2. "Tic Tac" Case 14 Nov 2004 (briefing slide), US Navy FOIA Reading Room
  3. Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena: Implications on National Security, Public Safety, and Government Transparency (hearing transcript, Serial No. 118-53), US House of Representatives, Committee on Oversight and Accountability (26 July 2023)
  4. Glowing Auras and 'Black Money': The Pentagon's Mysterious U.F.O. Program, The New York Times (16 December 2017)
  5. Navy pilots recall "unsettling" 2004 UAP sighting, CBS News (60 Minutes) (16 May 2021)
  6. Navy Pilot Who Filmed the 'Tic Tac' UFO Speaks: 'It Wasn't Behaving by the Normal Laws of Physics', New York magazine (Intelligencer) (19 December 2019)
  7. 2004 USS Nimitz Tic Tac UFO FLIR footage (FLIR1), Metabunk (Mick West) (23 October 2017)
  8. UAP Imagery, All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office
  9. Pentagon's Former Top UFO Hunter Speaks Out on UAPs and Aliens, Newsweek (25 January 2024)
  10. Navy pilot remembers the 'absurdity' of her famous UFO sighting, Task & Purpose (27 May 2021)

Unexplained News is researched and written with the help of AI tools, working only from the public sources linked in each article. We keep what's documented apart from what's claimed, and we correct mistakes openly. Spotted a mistake? Email [email protected]. Our editorial standards. This article in plain Markdown.

Seen something you can't explain? Tell us your story.

Read next