# Sapphire Canyon: the Mars rock sample NASA calls a potential biosignature

> Not proof of life, but the best candidate yet. Sapphire Canyon, a rock core Perseverance drilled in July 2024, holds minerals and organic carbon that microbes often make on Earth. Non-biological chemistry is not ruled out, and only a lab on Earth could settle it.

- **Published:** 20 November 2026
- **Topic:** Space & the search for life
- **Type:** Explainer
- **Case status:** Under investigation (Being actively studied. The results that could settle it aren't in yet.)
- **Where:** Jezero crater, Mars
- **When it happened:** 10 September 2025
- **Reading time:** 7 min
- **Web page:** https://stillcantexplain.com/news/mars-perseverance-potential-biosignature-sapphire-canyon

## Key facts

- NASA announced on 10 September 2025 that Sapphire Canyon, a rock core Perseverance drilled on 21 July 2024 from the 'Cheyava Falls' rock in Jezero crater, contains potential biosignatures.
- Cheyava Falls is speckled with millimetre-scale 'leopard spots' and 'poppy seeds' rich in minerals that are most likely vivianite and greigite, which on Earth often form when microbes feed on organic matter.
- The peer-reviewed study, led by Joel Hurowitz of Stony Brook University, was published in Nature on 10 September 2025 and says analysis on Earth is needed to determine how the features formed.
- Non-biological chemistry can make the same minerals. The rocks show no sign of the high temperatures or acidity that usually requires, but NASA scientists say abiotic explanations cannot be ruled out.
- As of October 2026 no mission is funded to return the sample: NASA's 2026 budget gave Mars Sample Return nothing, and ESA said in January 2026 that, on current plans, the mission would not go ahead.
- China's Tianwen-3 mission is scheduled to launch around 2028 and return at least 500 grams of its own Martian samples, not Perseverance's, by around 2031.

On 10 September 2025, NASA announced that a core of Martian rock called Sapphire Canyon contains "potential biosignatures": chemical and mineral patterns that microbes could have left behind billions of years ago. The Perseverance rover drilled the sample on 21 July 2024 from a reddish rock nicknamed Cheyava Falls, on the edge of an ancient river valley that once fed Jezero crater.

The mission team calls it [its best candidate yet](https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/nasa-says-mars-rover-discovered-potential-biosignature-last-year/) for signs of ancient microbial life. It is not proof of life. Non-biological chemistry has not been ruled out, only a laboratory on Earth could settle the question, and as of October 2026 no mission is funded to bring the sample home.

## What Perseverance found at Cheyava Falls

Perseverance reached Cheyava Falls in July 2024 while exploring the Bright Angel formation, outcrops along the edges of Neretva Vallis, a valley about 400 metres (a quarter of a mile) wide carved by water rushing into Jezero crater. The formation's rocks are mudstones of clay and silt, sediments that preserve traces of microbial life well on Earth.

The rock, named after a Grand Canyon waterfall, is arrowhead-shaped and measures about 1 metre by 0.6 metres (3.2 by 2 feet). White veins of calcium sulfate run along it, with reddish bands between them that suggest hematite, the iron oxide behind Mars's rusty colour, according to [NASA's first announcement in July 2024](https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/nasas-perseverance-rover-scientists-find-intriguing-mars-rock/).

Up close, the rover's PIXL X-ray instrument and its SHERLOC organic-chemistry instrument found two kinds of marking in the red bands: tiny dark specks the team called "poppy seeds", and larger pale blotches with dark rims, which they called "leopard spots". SHERLOC also detected organic compounds.

Perseverance drilled Sapphire Canyon, its 22nd rock core, from the same block on 21 July 2024. After probing the rock with lasers, X-rays and cameras, Ken Farley, then the mission's project scientist, said: "Scientifically, Perseverance has nothing more to give."

## Why the leopard spots matter

According to the [peer-reviewed paper in Nature](https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-025-09413-0), the leopard spots are about 0.2 to 1 millimetre across and look like reaction fronts that formed inside the rock, not grains washed in. Their dark rims and the poppy seeds are rich in iron and phosphorus, consistent with vivianite, a hydrated iron phosphate. Their pale cores are rich in iron and sulfur, consistent with greigite, an iron sulfide. Both identifications are probable rather than certain, since they rest on the rover's chemical readings.

The interest lies in the chemistry. Vivianite holds iron in a chemically reduced form and greigite holds sulfur as sulfide, both apparently produced as organic matter gave up electrons inside a rock that is otherwise oxidised and red. In muddy sediments on Earth, microbes live off exactly these reactions: they consume organic matter and pass the electrons to iron, then to sulfate once the iron runs out. [The Planetary Society's analysis](https://www.planetary.org/articles/our-best-proof-of-life-on-mars-yet-a-deep-dive-into-cheyava-falls) explains how that sequence would neatly leave pale greigite cores ringed by dark vivianite.

> The combination of chemical compounds we found in the Bright Angel formation could have been a rich source of energy for microbial metabolisms.
> — Joel Hurowitz, Stony Brook University, lead author of the Nature paper, 10 September 2025

NASA also noted that these are among the youngest sedimentary rocks Perseverance has studied. That suggests Mars may have stayed habitable for longer, or later in its history, than previously thought.

## What "potential biosignature" means

Hurowitz and a large team of mission scientists submitted their paper, "Redox-driven mineral and organic associations in Jezero Crater, Mars", in November 2024, and Nature published it on 10 September 2025. It concludes that the Bright Angel mudstones contain textures, minerals and organic signatures that "warrant consideration as 'potential biosignatures'".

The phrase has a specific, modest meaning. NASA defines a potential biosignature as "a substance or structure that might have a biological origin but requires more data or further study before a conclusion can be reached about the absence or presence of life." It is a reason to look harder, not a detection. When the results were first presented in March 2025, the find sat [at one on a scale of one to seven](https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/if-life-on-mars-ever-existed-this-bizarre-rock-may-tell-us/) on the Confidence of Life Detection (CoLD) scale devised by NASA scientists, with seven reserved for confirmation.

Sean Duffy, then NASA's acting administrator, called the find "the closest we have ever come to discovering life on Mars". The mission's own scientists were more guarded.

> Astrobiological claims, particularly those related to the potential discovery of past extraterrestrial life, require extraordinary evidence.
> — Katie Stack Morgan, Perseverance project scientist, NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory, 10 September 2025

## The non-biological explanations still on the table

The paper treats a non-biological origin as its null hypothesis, the explanation to beat, and tests the main ways to make the same minerals without life:

- **Organic chemistry alone.** Many organic compounds can break down rust-like iron oxide minerals without microbes, at 10 °C to 80 °C. Whether the organics in Cheyava Falls can do so is unknown.
- **Heat or acid.** Hot or acidic fluids can make these minerals, but NASA says the Bright Angel rocks show no evidence of either. Without life, turning sulfate into sulfide is exceedingly slow below about 150 °C to 200 °C, which here would have required burial more than 5 kilometres deep.
- **Sulfide from elsewhere.** Volcanic or hydrothermal activity could have delivered sulfide in groundwater. The team found no sign of such systems in the rocks Perseverance had explored, and sulfide seeping in from outside would be expected to leave diffuse splotches rather than sharp spots, The Planetary Society notes.
- **Hot veins.** In 2024 the team asked whether olivine in the rock's veins, a mineral that crystallises from magma, meant the spots formed in uninhabitably hot fluids.

A March 2026 follow-up in Nature Communications, by several of the same scientists, reported record nickel levels for Martian bedrock in nearby iron sulfides. It suggested that hydrogen released as water reacts with olivine-rich rock, a process called serpentinisation, could also have driven the chemistry without biology.

There is a wider reason for caution. Pale "reduction spots" occur in red rocks on Earth, and while some researchers argue that microbes help make them, the Nature paper notes this is "not a universally held perspective". Stack Morgan says abiotic explanations are "less likely given the paper's findings", but "we cannot rule them out". Jim Bell, a co-author and principal investigator for one of the rover's instruments, gave The Planetary Society the simplest reason of all: "It's on Mars." Scientists have "never found any evidence of past or current life on Mars", he said.

## Mars Sample Return: where things stand in October 2026

Sapphire Canyon is sealed in a sample tube aboard Perseverance, waiting for a ride off Mars. NASA's Mars Sample Return programme, with the European Space Agency (ESA) building the Earth Return Orbiter, was meant to provide one. But cost estimates climbed as high as $11 billion, with the samples not due back until 2040, [Aerospace America reported](https://aerospaceamerica.aiaa.org/european-space-agency-rethinks-mars-plans-as-it-kicks-off-a-mission-dense-2026/).

The Trump administration proposed not funding the existing plan, and Congress agreed. The 2026 spending law passed in mid-January 2026 gave Mars Sample Return nothing and formally closed its programme office, [according to The Planetary Society](https://www.planetary.org/articles/advocacy-success-fy2026-nasa-budget). It did provide $110 million for a new "Mars Future Missions" project to develop shared technologies for robotic and crewed missions, sample return among them.

ESA's director general, Josef Aschbacher, said in January 2026: "we understand that, at least according to today's plans, the mission will not go ahead, so we are evaluating ESA's contribution to it." Daniel Neuenschwander, ESA's director of human and robotic exploration, added that "Europe cannot afford, on its own, a full Mars Sample Return mission".

No replacement has been approved since. As of October 2026, Congress has not passed NASA's budget for the financial year that began on 1 October, and the agency is running on a [stopgap that holds it at 2026 levels](https://spacepolicyonline.com/news/house-clears-fy2027-cr-now-to-the-president/) until 11 December 2026.

The only mission with a timetable for bringing rock back from the Martian surface is China's. Tianwen-3's chief scientist, Hou Zengqian, said in July 2025 that it is [scheduled to launch around 2028](https://english.www.gov.cn/news/202507/23/content_WS68803af3c6d0868f4e8f45d3.html) and return at least 500 grams of Martian material by around 2031. It would collect its own samples at its own landing site, not Perseverance's.

## What would count as proof

Everyone involved agrees on the next step. The Nature paper concludes that analysing the core "using high-sensitivity instrumentation on Earth" will enable the measurements needed to determine the origin of its minerals, organics and textures. In a laboratory, scientists could run tests no rover can carry, such as isotopic studies that could help reveal whether microbes were involved.

Even that would be only part of the case. A NASA explainer on [what it would take to say we have found life](https://www.nasa.gov/science-research/planetary-science/astrobiology/what-would-it-take-to-say-we-found-life-we-asked-a-nasa-expert-episode-63/) lists the tests any claim must pass: is the signal real, could it be contamination from Earth, could such life have lived there, could any non-biological process, known or unknown, make it, and do independent lines of evidence agree? Then the wider scientific community has to be convinced.

History counsels patience. In 1996 scientists claimed signs of life in the Martian meteorite ALH84001, only for others to explain the features through geology. The same discipline applies to every extraordinary claim, from Mars rocks to [interstellar visitors such as 3I/ATLAS](https://stillcantexplain.com/news/3i-atlas-interstellar-object-alien-technology).

## What we still can't explain

Nobody yet knows whether microbes made the leopard spots. The open questions are specific: could the organic matter in the Bright Angel mudstones have reduced the iron on its own at low temperatures, where did that organic carbon come from, and could some untested non-biological process reproduce the same pattern of spots?

Laboratory experiments, modelling and studies of similar rocks on Earth can chip away at those questions, as the paper recommends. The decisive measurements need the rock itself. As of October 2026, Sapphire Canyon remains on Mars inside a rover, with no funded way home, and Cheyava Falls stays what NASA calls it: the best candidate yet.

## Questions people ask

### Has NASA found evidence of life on Mars?

No. NASA says the Sapphire Canyon sample, drilled by the Perseverance rover in July 2024, contains potential biosignatures: features that might have a biological origin but need more study before anyone can say whether life was involved. The minerals and organic carbon in the Cheyava Falls rock fit a microbial explanation, but non-biological chemistry has not been ruled out, and the scientists say laboratory analysis on Earth is needed to decide.

### What are the leopard spots on the Cheyava Falls rock?

The leopard spots are pale blotches with dark rims, about 0.2 to 1 millimetre across, in the reddish mudstone of the Cheyava Falls rock in Jezero crater. Perseverance's instruments found the rims rich in iron and phosphorus, consistent with the mineral vivianite, and the cores rich in iron and sulfur, consistent with greigite. They appear to be reaction fronts where organic matter reacted with iron and sulfate inside the rock.

### Could the leopard spots on Mars have formed without life?

Possibly. Vivianite and greigite can form without microbes, for example in hot or acidic conditions, or where organic compounds react with iron minerals on their own. The Nature paper on the Sapphire Canyon sample found no evidence that the Bright Angel rocks were heated or acidic, which makes the simplest non-biological routes less likely, but it is unknown whether the rock's organic compounds could drive the reactions without life at low temperatures.

### When will the Sapphire Canyon sample be brought back to Earth?

There is no date. As of October 2026 the Sapphire Canyon sample is still on Mars, sealed inside the Perseverance rover, and no mission is funded to collect it. Congress gave NASA's Mars Sample Return programme no money in its 2026 budget, and the European Space Agency is reconsidering its part of the plan. China's Tianwen-3, due to launch around 2028, would bring back its own samples, not Perseverance's.

## Sources

1. [NASA Says Mars Rover Discovered Potential Biosignature Last Year](https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/nasa-says-mars-rover-discovered-potential-biosignature-last-year/) — NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory, 2025-09-10
2. [Redox-driven mineral and organic associations in Jezero Crater, Mars](https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-025-09413-0) — Nature, 2025-09-10
3. [NASA's Perseverance Rover Scientists Find Intriguing Mars Rock](https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/nasas-perseverance-rover-scientists-find-intriguing-mars-rock/) — NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory, 2024-07-25
4. [Our best proof of life on Mars yet? A deep dive into Cheyava Falls](https://www.planetary.org/articles/our-best-proof-of-life-on-mars-yet-a-deep-dive-into-cheyava-falls) — The Planetary Society, 2025-10-09
5. [If Life on Mars Ever Existed, This Bizarre Rock May Tell Us](https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/if-life-on-mars-ever-existed-this-bizarre-rock-may-tell-us/) — Scientific American (reproduced from Nature), 2025-03-12
6. [What Would It Take to Say We Found Life? We Asked a NASA Expert: Episode 63](https://www.nasa.gov/science-research/planetary-science/astrobiology/what-would-it-take-to-say-we-found-life-we-asked-a-nasa-expert-episode-63/) — NASA, 2025-09-10
7. [You just saved NASA's budget](https://www.planetary.org/articles/advocacy-success-fy2026-nasa-budget) — The Planetary Society, 2026-01-15
8. [European Space Agency rethinks Mars plans as it kicks off a ‘mission-dense’ 2026](https://aerospaceamerica.aiaa.org/european-space-agency-rethinks-mars-plans-as-it-kicks-off-a-mission-dense-2026/) — Aerospace America (AIAA), 2026-01-08
9. [House Clears FY2027 CR, Now to the President](https://spacepolicyonline.com/news/house-clears-fy2027-cr-now-to-the-president/) — SpacePolicyOnline, 2026-09-01
10. [Chinese scientist details first planned Mars sample-return mission Tianwen-3](https://english.www.gov.cn/news/202507/23/content_WS68803af3c6d0868f4e8f45d3.html) — Xinhua via english.gov.cn, 2025-07-23

---

Unexplained News is researched and written with the help of AI tools, working only from the public sources linked in each article. We keep what's documented apart from what's claimed, and we correct mistakes openly. Spotted a mistake? Email stillcantexplain@outlook.com.

Unexplained News, from Still Can't Explain: https://stillcantexplain.com/news
