Explainer · Space & the search for life · Case status: Explained
3I/ATLAS: why the third interstellar object is a comet, not alien technology
No, 3I/ATLAS is not an alien spacecraft. Every measurement of the third known interstellar object fits a natural comet from another star system. Avi Loeb's anomalies drew global attention, but radio searches found no signals and the testable oddities have natural explanations.
By The Unexplained News desk. Published . 7 min read.
Case status: Explained. A well-supported, conventional explanation fits the evidence.
When: 1 July 2025.
Key facts
- 3I/ATLAS was discovered on 1 July 2025 by the NASA-funded ATLAS survey telescope at Río Hurtado, Chile. It is only the third interstellar object ever seen, after ʻOumuamua in 2017 and 2I/Borisov in 2019.
- It was travelling at about 221,000 km/h when found and about 246,000 km/h at perihelion on 29 October 2025, when it passed 203 million km from the Sun, just inside the orbit of Mars.
- 3I/ATLAS passed 29 million km from Mars on 3 October 2025, came no closer than about 270 million km to Earth on 19 December 2025, and passed about 54 million km from Jupiter on 16 March 2026.
- Harvard astrophysicist Avi Loeb argued it could be alien technology, citing anomalies such as an orbit within 5 degrees of the planets' plane and an early excess of nickel over iron in its gas.
- NASA and ESA say every observation fits a comet. Radio searches found no artificial signals, and its nickel-to-iron ratio became indistinguishable from other comets' as it neared the Sun.
- A June 2026 Nature study found its water far richer in deuterium than any known comet's and, from its carbon isotopes, concluded it may have formed as long as 12 billion years ago.
3I/ATLAS is a comet from another star system, and only the third interstellar object ever detected. Found on 1 July 2025 by a NASA-funded survey telescope in Chile, it swept through the inner Solar System at up to about 246,000 km/h (153,000 mph), passing Mars in early October, rounding the Sun just inside Mars’s orbit at the end of that month and passing Jupiter in March 2026.
For a few months it was also one of the most argued-about objects in the sky, after Harvard astrophysicist Avi Loeb suggested it might be alien technology. The evidence gathered since, from the Hubble and James Webb space telescopes, a fleet of spacecraft and searches for artificial radio signals, points one way: 3I/ATLAS is a natural comet, though an unusually strange and ancient one.
How 3I/ATLAS was found
The Asteroid Terrestrial-impact Last Alert System (ATLAS), part of NASA’s planetary defence network, spotted the object from its telescope at Río Hurtado in Chile and reported it to the Minor Planet Center on 1 July 2025, according to NASA. It was about 670 million km from the Sun, inside the orbit of Jupiter, and approaching from the direction of Sagittarius, the part of the sky where the centre of our galaxy lies.
Its orbit gave it away. The discovery team calculated an eccentricity of about 6.1 (anything above 1 is not bound to the Sun) and a speed through interstellar space of about 58 km per second. Its path is tilted by about 175 degrees: it travels the opposite way to the planets, but within about 5 degrees of their orbital plane.
Its name means it is the third interstellar object (3I), discovered by ATLAS. Its comet designation is C/2025 N1 (ATLAS).
How it compares with ʻOumuamua and Borisov
| 1I/ʻOumuamua | 2I/Borisov | 3I/ATLAS | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Discovered | 2017 | 2019 | 1 July 2025 |
| Speed through interstellar space | about 26 km/s | about 32 km/s | about 58 km/s |
| Nucleus (effective radius) | about 0.08 km, highly aspherical | about 0.4 km | about 1.3 km |
ʻOumuamua remains the strangest of the three: it showed no coma, yet its path revealed a small non-gravitational acceleration. Borisov was a textbook comet, if unusually rich in carbon monoxide. 3I/ATLAS is a comet too, but faster and bigger than both: Hubble images from December 2025 and January 2026 put its nucleus at about 2.6 km (1.6 miles) across, assuming a typically dark comet surface. ESA says its speed suggests it has drifted between the stars for billions of years.
Its path, speed and closest approaches
- 1 July 2025: discovered about 670 million km from the Sun, moving at about 221,000 km/h.
- 3 October 2025: closest approach to Mars, at about 29 million km.
- 29 October 2025: perihelion, its closest point to the Sun, at about 203 million km, just inside the orbit of Mars. Earth was on the far side of the Sun. Its speed peaked at about 246,000 km/h.
- 19 December 2025: closest approach to Earth, at about 270 million km, 1.8 times the Earth–Sun distance. It was never a danger.
- 16 March 2026: closest approach to Jupiter, at about 54 million km, according to NASA’s JPL Horizons ephemeris.
Like other comets, it was nudged slightly by its own outgassing; NASA says these perturbations “were indeed small and compatible with this process”. As of October 2026, 3I/ATLAS is about 12 times Earth’s distance from the Sun, beyond the orbit of Saturn, and leaving for interstellar space.
What telescopes and spacecraft saw
Few comets have been watched so closely. ESA and NASA turned observatories and planetary probes across the Solar System towards it:
- Hubble saw it already active in summer 2025, shedding dust from its Sun-warmed side.
- The James Webb Space Telescope found carbon dioxide, water, carbon monoxide, carbonyl sulphide and water ice in its coma in August 2025, and measured the isotopes in its water in December.
- At Mars, ESA’s Mars Express and ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter, and NASA’s Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter, MAVEN and Perseverance rover, observed it. Trace Gas Orbiter data improved predictions of its position tenfold.
- Elsewhere, NASA’s Psyche, Lucy, SPHEREx, Parker Solar Probe, PUNCH and STEREO, and the ESA–NASA SOHO observatory, tracked it. ESA’s Jupiter-bound Juice watched it in November 2025, soon after perihelion, when it was very active.
- X-ray telescopes XRISM and XMM-Newton detected a faint glow around it in late 2025, the first time an interstellar comet has been seen in X-rays.
The case Avi Loeb made
On 16 July 2025, Loeb and two colleagues, Adam Hibberd and Adam Crowl, posted a paper titled “Is the Interstellar Object 3I/ATLAS Alien Technology?”. They called it “largely a pedagogical exercise”, then hypothesised that the object “could be technological, and possibly hostile”. They argued that its path passes surprisingly close to Venus, Mars and Jupiter, with a probability of about 0.005 per cent or less, and that being hidden behind the Sun from Earth at perihelion would let a spacecraft brake unseen.
His running list of anomalies, as summarised on his blog in April 2026, included:
- an orbit aligned within 5 degrees of the planets’ plane, which he put at a 0.2 per cent chance;
- timing that brought it close to Mars, and past Jupiter at almost exactly the radius of its gravitational sphere of influence, while hiding perihelion from Earth;
- a narrow, sunward “anti-tail” jet before and after perihelion;
- gas with much more nickel than iron, which he compared to industrial nickel alloys;
- a nucleus more massive than ʻOumuamua’s or Borisov’s, moving faster than both;
- unusual polarisation of its light, rapid brightening near perihelion and very high deuterium levels;
- an arrival direction within 9 degrees of an unexplained radio signal detected in 1977.
He ranks it level 4 on his own 0-to-10 “Loeb Scale” for interstellar objects, but stresses what he is not saying: “I am not claiming that 3I/ATLAS is technological but only stating that we should consider its anomalies with this possibility in mind,” he wrote in December 2025.
How other astronomers answered
The space agencies were unequivocal. “3I/ATLAS’s characteristics, color, speed, and direction are all consistent with what we expect from a comet,” NASA says. ESA says its shape and behaviour indicate a comet, and notes of the sunward dust plume Hubble saw: “Comets originating within our own Solar System display similar behaviour.”
Many astronomers objected to the statistics. In an exchange Loeb published on his blog, Princeton astrophysicist Josh Winn argued that probabilities worked out after the fact mislead, because almost any path could be made to look meaningful in hindsight.
A problem with the hypothesis that 3I/ATLAS is of technological origin is that it is very flexible, because of the unknown goals and technologies involved, and can therefore be retrospectively considered compatible with just about any anomaly.
— Josh Winn, Princeton University, in an email published by Avi Loeb on 18 December 2025
The most direct test was to listen. The SETI Institute’s Allen Telescope Array and South Africa’s MeerKAT searched for artificial radio signals, and on 18 December 2025, a day before its closest approach to Earth, Breakthrough Listen pointed the Green Bank Telescope at it. None found any credible signal. “There is currently no evidence to suggest that ISOs are anything other than natural astrophysical objects,” the Breakthrough Listen team wrote.
What later observations established
The anomalies that could be tested have mostly dissolved into comet science:
- The nickel came with iron after all. Very Large Telescope spectra showed nickel from the start but iron only once the comet was within 2.64 times Earth’s distance from the Sun. Closer in, its nickel-to-iron ratio “became indistinguishable from those observed in Solar System comets and in comet 2I/Borisov”, Damien Hutsemékers and colleagues found. They attribute the early imbalance to nickel and iron carbonyls, compounds that vaporise at different temperatures. Loeb’s April summary notes that “After perihelion, iron was detected.”
- Its size fits its behaviour. The Hubble nucleus measurement matches an independent estimate from the push of its outgassing, and its fading after perihelion was “not unusual in the context of solar system comets”.
- It is natural, but alien in origin. A June 2026 study in Nature, led by Martin Cordiner of NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center, found a deuterium-to-hydrogen ratio in its water of about 0.98 per cent, more than ten times that of known comets, plus unusual carbon isotope ratios. It concludes the comet formed below about 30 kelvin (-243 °C) in a metal-poor environment, possibly as long as 12 billion years ago, long before the Sun: “a preserved fragment of an ancient planetary system”. UK schoolchildren in the Comet Chasers outreach programme contributed supporting observations.
- No artificial light. Even Loeb wrote in April 2026 that “its fading light curve does not show any evidence for artificial (self-produced) light”.
What we still can’t explain
Very little about what 3I/ATLAS is remains in doubt: it is a comet, and no measurement has pointed to technology. The open questions concern the star system that made it. Why are its ices so rich in carbon dioxide and deuterium? Why did it shed nickel and iron atoms at least ten times faster than other comets? Why does its dust polarise light in a way never before seen in a comet or asteroid?
Some of Loeb’s items, such as its alignment with the planets, can never be settled: they are one-off coincidences, not measurements, and the object will not return. The Hubble team infers that similar visitors probably slipped past unnoticed before ʻOumuamua, so future finds should show whether 3I/ATLAS is typical. Until then it is a free sample of another planetary system, judged by the same standard of evidence as potential biosignatures on Mars.
Questions people ask
Is 3I/ATLAS an alien spacecraft?
No evidence supports that idea. NASA and ESA say every observation of 3I/ATLAS fits a natural comet: it has an icy nucleus, a coma and tails, and gives off carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide and water vapour as the Sun warms its ices. Radio searches with the Allen Telescope Array, MeerKAT and the Green Bank Telescope found no artificial signals. Avi Loeb, who raised the possibility, has said he is not claiming it is technological.
How fast is 3I/ATLAS travelling?
When 3I/ATLAS was discovered in July 2025 it was moving at about 221,000 km/h (137,000 mph), according to NASA. The Sun's gravity sped it up to about 246,000 km/h (153,000 mph) at perihelion on 29 October 2025. Its speed through interstellar space, before the Sun's pull took hold, is about 58 km per second, roughly twice that of ʻOumuamua, the first interstellar object.
How is 3I/ATLAS different from ʻOumuamua and Borisov?
ʻOumuamua, found in 2017, showed no coma but accelerated slightly in a way that has never been fully explained. 2I/Borisov, found in 2019, was an obvious comet. 3I/ATLAS is an active comet like Borisov, but faster and much larger than both: Hubble measurements put its nucleus at about 1.3 km in radius, against roughly 0.08 km for ʻOumuamua and 0.4 km for Borisov.
Where is 3I/ATLAS now?
As of October 2026, 3I/ATLAS is heading out of the Solar System for good, about 12 times Earth's distance from the Sun and beyond the orbit of Saturn, according to NASA's JPL Horizons ephemeris. It passed Jupiter at about 54 million km on 16 March 2026 and is now fading from view. Because it is on a hyperbolic path, it will never return.
Sources
- 3I/ATLAS Facts and FAQs, NASA (13 November 2025)
- Comet 3I/ATLAS – frequently asked questions, European Space Agency
- Isotopic evidence for a cold and distant origin of 3I/ATLAS, Nature (22 June 2026)
- Is the Interstellar Object 3I/ATLAS Alien Technology?, arXiv (Hibberd, Crowl and Loeb) (16 July 2025)
- Where is 3I/ATLAS Now?, Avi Loeb (Medium) (23 April 2026)
- Pre-perihelion evolution of the NiI/FeI abundance ratio in the coma of the interstellar comet 3I/ATLAS. From extreme to normal, arXiv (accepted by Astronomy & Astrophysics) (30 September 2025)
- Nucleus and Postperihelion Activity of Interstellar Object 3I/ATLAS Observed by Hubble Space Telescope, arXiv (accepted by The Astrophysical Journal Letters) (29 January 2026)
- Breakthrough Listen Observations of 3I/ATLAS with the Green Bank Telescope at 1-12 GHz, arXiv (Breakthrough Listen) (20 December 2025)
- Discovery and Preliminary Characterization of a Third Interstellar Object: 3I/ATLAS, arXiv (accepted by The Astrophysical Journal Letters) (3 July 2025)
- The 15 Anomalies of 3I/ATLAS: Should We Pay Attention to Them if They Were Not Forecasted?, Avi Loeb (Medium) (18 December 2025)
Unexplained News is researched and written with the help of AI tools, working only from the public sources linked in each article. We keep what's documented apart from what's claimed, and we correct mistakes openly. Spotted a mistake? Email [email protected]. Our editorial standards. This article in plain Markdown.
Seen something you can't explain? Tell us your story.
Read next
- Sapphire Canyon: the Mars rock sample NASA calls a potential biosignature: Not proof of life, but the best candidate yet. Sapphire Canyon, a rock core Perseverance drilled in July 2024, holds minerals and organic carbon that microbes often make on Earth. Non-biological chemistry is not ruled out, and only a lab on Earth could settle it.
- PURSUE UFO files: what is in the Pentagon's sixth release of declassified UAP records: The Pentagon's sixth batch of declassified UAP files, published at war.gov/ufo on 18 September 2026, adds the 1952 Tremonton film, a 1952 Air Force briefing tape, Middle East infrared video and Colorado police clips. Every case is labelled unresolved, not explained.
- What is AARO? The Pentagon's UFO office explained: its findings, reports and critics: AARO, the All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office, is the US Defense Department office investigating UAP, the official name for UFOs. Set up in 2022, it has resolved hundreds of cases as balloons, birds, drones or satellites, and says it has seen no evidence of alien technology.